CrossTrade vs Replikanto: Architecture, Synchronization, and the Future of Trade Copying

Replikanto from FlowBots has established itself as a popular choice among NinjaTrader traders, particularly for those managing multiple prop firm accounts. But when you examine the architectural differences and synchronization approaches, CrossTrade represents a fundamental evolution in how trade copying should work.

The Multi-Directional Architecture Gap

Replikanto operates on the traditional leader-follower hierarchy. One leader account pushes trades to multiple follower accounts. You can configure different copy methods and ratios, but the relationship structure itself is rigid and unidirectional.

Need Account A to follow B while B follows C, and C feeds back to A? Not possible.
Want to create circular copying networks for sophisticated hedging? Not supported. Need bidirectional relationships where accounts both send and receive? Replikanto's architecture doesn't allow it.

CrossTrade's Multi-Directional Approach

CrossTrade eliminates these architectural constraints entirely. Any NinjaTrader 8 account can simultaneously copy from and send trades to any other account in your network.

This enables trading architectures that are impossible with traditional copiers:

• Your main strategy copies to multiple prop challenges while those same prop accounts feed specific setups back to a master hedging account
• Account A follows ES trades from Leader X and NQ trades from Leader Y simultaneously
• Create circular copying networks for advanced portfolio management

The difference isn't just features, it's foundational architecture that determines what's possible.

The Synchronization Philosophy: Reactive vs Continuous

Here's where the approaches diverge fundamentally.

Replikanto's Approach

Replikanto operates on reactive logic with extensive configuration options:

• Seven copy methods (Exact Quantity, Equal Quantity, Ratio, Net Liquidation, Available Money, Percentage Change, Pre Allocation)
• Market Only execution mode for speed
• Follower Guard to close and disarm positions in certain scenarios
• ATM Copy feature for exit order management

These are sophisticated tools, but they still require you to anticipate and configure for edge cases. What happens with partial fills? Connection drops? Timing mismatches? You configure settings and hope they cover your scenarios.

CrossTrade's Auto-Sync Paradigm

Auto-Sync represents a completely different philosophy. Instead of trying to predict and configure every edge case, CrossTrade continuously monitors and realigns your accounts every 3 seconds.

It acts as an insurance policy that fixes discrepancies automatically based on your copier configuration:

• Accidentally close a position on a follower? Auto-Sync reopens it within 3 seconds
• Connection disruption? Upon reconnection, Auto-Sync immediately resumes synchronization
• NinjaTrader crashes and restarts? Auto-Sync resumes state synchronization automatically
• Partial fills create mismatches? Auto-Sync detects and corrects

Prop Firm Stealth: Recent Addition vs Core Architecture

Replikanto added Stealth Mode in recent updates (version 1.6+), responding to increased prop firm automation detection. This is a positive development, but it's a feature added to existing architecture.

CrossTrade's Purpose-Built Stealth Mode

CrossTrade's Stealth Mode was designed from the ground up as a core architectural component. Orders appear identical to manual entries with natural timing characteristics and authentic order flow patterns.

The critical difference: CrossTrade's Stealth Mode can recover its order mapping relationships even after catastrophic failures like connection losses or complete NinjaTrader restarts. This recovery capability while maintaining stealth is non-trivial engineering.

Copy Method Flexibility

Replikanto's Strength: Seven Copy Methods

This is where Replikanto excels. Seven distinct copy methods provide granular control over how positions are distributed:

1. Exact Quantity - copies exact volume to all accounts
2. Pooled/Equal Quantity - distributes contracts equally
3. Ratio - define custom ratios from -100 to 100 (including negative for inversion)
4. Pre Allocation - pre-defined quantity per follower
5. Net Liquidation - distributes based on account liquidation values
6. Available Money - distributes based on available equity
7. Percentage Change - increases or decreases existing positions by percentage

This is genuinely impressive and provides more copy method options than any competitor.

CrossTrade's Approach

CrossTrade uses flexible ratio-based scaling with maximum position limits. Set followers to trade at any ratio (0.5x, 2x, custom), and maximum limits ensure accounts never breach individual risk thresholds.

The implementation is simpler with fewer method variations, but CrossTrade's Auto-Sync ensures that whatever ratios you set are maintained continuously and automatically.

Symbol Replacement and Cross Orders

Replikanto's Cross Order Feature

Replikanto offers pre-defined instrument pairs (ES↔MES, NQ↔MNQ, YM↔MYM, etc.) with the ability to customize cross order instruments at any time. This is solid functionality that works well for mini-to-micro conversions.

CrossTrade's Symbol Replacement

CrossTrade handles symbol replacement with automatic contract mathematics. When your source trades ES, the follower executes using MES while maintaining identical trade logic and proper proportional exposure. All timing and risk management relationships are preserved automatically.

TradingView Integration: The Unbridgeable Gap

Here's where CrossTrade achieves something Replikanto simply cannot match.

Replikanto can copy trades from TradingView-connected NinjaTrader accounts. If you execute trades through TradingView that route to NT, Replikanto will copy them to follower accounts. This works, but it's not true TradingView manual trading.

CrossTrade is the first and only solution that enables direct manual trading from TradingView to NinjaTrader 8 desktop.

Execute trades on TradingView's interface—market orders, limit orders, bracket setups, stop adjustments—and watch them instantly appear in NT8 with full order management capabilities. The copier translates TradingView's order types into proper NT8 formats automatically.

This isn't just a feature difference. It's solving a workflow problem that thousands of traders have wanted for years: TradingView's superior charting with NT8's professional execution environment, all working seamlessly together.

Network and Remote Mode

Replikanto's Network/Remote Capabilities

Replikanto supports both network mode (same local network) and remote mode (over internet). This is valuable for traders running multiple machines or VPS instances.

However, remote mode requires purchasing credits ($10-90) in addition to the base license cost, and you need a Replikanto license on each machine.

CrossTrade's Approach

CrossTrade focuses on single-machine deployment with the ability to connect any NT8 accounts on that machine. The architecture is designed for traders running multiple NT instances on one machine or using VPS.

Execution Modes

Both copiers offer execution mode flexibility:

Replikanto:

• Market Only mode for execution-focused copying
• Standard order copying mode
• ATM Copy feature for exit order management

CrossTrade:

• Order Mode for ultra-precise synchronization
• Execution Mode for speed-focused market order copying
• Mix and match modes across different copy relationships

Risk Management

Replikanto includes Follower Guard to protect accounts by closing positions and disarming copying in certain scenarios. It's reactive protection that requires manual restart after triggering.

CrossTrade provides Tandem Mode, which binds copying behavior to NinjaTrader Account Manager monitors. Copying only runs while the Account Manager is active and within risk parameters. Hit limits, copying stops instantly—but Auto-Sync also means that when you manually restart, synchronization resumes immediately and intelligently.

Pricing Reality

Replikanto: $249 for 2 machines (lifetime), additional machines $49-99, remote mode requires credits ($10-90). This can become incredibly costly over time.

CrossTrade: Included with Pro subscription ($49) along with automated trading, advanced alert management, TradingView integration, and continuous updates

Replikanto uses one-time pricing with potential additional costs for remote features. CrossTrade includes the copier as part of a comprehensive trading platform.

The Verdict

Replikanto is a feature-rich trade copier with the most copy method variations in the market and solid network/remote capabilities.

But CrossTrade represents the next evolution:

Where CrossTrade Wins:

1. Multi-directional architecture - Build sophisticated networks impossible with Replikanto
2. Auto-Sync technology - Continuous intelligent synchronization vs reactive configuration
3. TradingView manual trading - Unique capability that doesn't exist in Replikanto
4. Bulletproof Stealth Mode - Core architecture vs recently-added feature
5. Tandem Mode - Tighter NT Account Manager integration
6. Active Development - CrossTrade's copier was released in October of 2025 with continued development planned to introduce more and more features.

Where Replikanto Wins:

1. Copy method variety - Seven methods vs CrossTrade's ratio-based approach
2. Network/Remote mode - Better for multi-machine deployments

For traders who need maximum copy method flexibility and multi-machine support, Replikanto is solid. But for traders who want architectural flexibility, bulletproof synchronization, TradingView integration, and the most advanced prop firm stealth available, CrossTrade is the clear choice.

Replikanto makes you configure for problems. CrossTrade solves problems automatically.

Learn more at crosstrade.io/trade-copier and give the CrossTrade NT8 Trade Copier a try, risk free, for 7 days.

Start your free trial

Try CrossTrade for 7 days.

Sign Up